Whiskey Hideaway

4.5 ( 163 reviews )
$20–30
2645 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10303, United States
+1 718-524-4662

Whiskey Hideaway, located in Staten Island, emerges as a vibrant culinary gem that has quickly captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. The combination of expertly crafted cocktails, including the standout Smokey Old Fashioned, and delicious comfort food has positioned this establishment as a must-visit. One guest raves about the wings, calling them some of the best on the island, while another highlights the enticing Jameson shrimp and cheesesteak empanadas, showcasing the diverse and flavorful menu.

Guests like Neil Parsons appreciate the friendly service and unique ambiance, noting that it's an excellent place for a family night out, complete with a pool hall atmosphere. Customers have enjoyed the attentiveness of the staff, from Andrew to Katelynn, adding a personal touch to the dining experience. The decor is described as cool, making it an inviting space for relaxation and enjoyment.

Overall, Whiskey Hideaway is not just a restaurant but a destination—a place to indulge in savory dishes and creative cocktails, all while engaging in fun activities like pool. With a dedicated following already forming, this eatery promises to be an essential part of Staten Island's dining scene. Highly recommended for foodies and cocktail enthusiasts alike!

Amenities and More

  • Service options
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Offerings
    • Serves alcohol
    • Serves beer
    • Serves cocktails
    • Serves spirits
  • Dining options
    • Serves dinner
  • Payments
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Parking
    • Free parking lot
    • Plenty of parking

Reviews For Whiskey Hideaway

Tom DeSantis
Jun 23,2025
The quality of the cocktails at Whiskey Hideaway are nothing short of incredible for a place on Staten Island. Makes you really feel like you’re somewhere else. The Smokey old fashioned is outstanding. And the wings are some of the best I’ve had on the Island, which in the case of wings is really saying something. Highly recommend to anyone in the area to check this place out for food and drinks, not to mention they have an entire room full of immaculate pool tables.
Neil Parsons
Jun 15,2025
Whiskey Hideaway is worth finding! Only open a couple of weeks, we enjoyed our family night evening. The food and specialty cocktails were tasty. Sophia, our server, was attentive and super friendly. The decor is cool. It was fun to be able to play a few games of pool after eating. IMO there should have been louder music playing. The place is too large to be quiet. They explained that they were having an issue with their Wi-Fi. We're all looking forward to our next visit.
Jeana A
May 6,2025
Jameson shrimp and cheesesteak empanadas.... Mmmm delish! Desert cocktail menu . Sampled only a fraction of the menu, but the food was hot and flavorful. Katelynn was sweet and attentive. Drinks were strong... love the barrels... overall a spot to check out!
trudy wisner
May 2,2025
My husband and I tried whiskey hide away this week for the first time. Our server Andrew was awesome. Quick, precise, pleasant. The food was delicious. And cocktails were perfect! Will be going back again.
David Fanning
May 2,2025
Whiskey Hideaway is absolutely what Staten Island has been missing. The food is great! I had the Elvis burger and shared the poutine (disco fries), cheesesteak empanadas, and pretzel sticks. Everything was top notch! The drinks were also good, and not your average offering. We really appreciated the professional pool hall on the other side of the bar. It looked like there were at least 10 tables and you rented them by the hour. I have not seen a pool set up like that with a hostess in years. Very nice, and definitely a reason to come back and hang out. Whiskey Hideaway is not just for dinner, it is a destination!
naomi vasquez
Apr 9,2025
Came with family food was delicious drinks were good. The ambiance was good as well. We also played pool after would definitely recommend to others. I got a double decker grilled cheese and I added a burger patty it was delicious!!
Daphne M
Mar 25,2025
Nice place to hang out with friends. Love the burger and bang bang shrimp. Table pools are inside the bar restaurant which we hung out there after dinner.
J W
Mar 12,2025
The restaurant is very spacious with ample amounts of television for sport fans, a wide selection of alcoholic beverages, a bunch of pool tables, and a good variety of foods. Terry provided great service as he was quick, friendly, and attuned to diners' needs. I got the truffled mushroom burger which was definitely quite big and flavorful, with a side of sweet potato waffle fries which was a bit too sweet for me since they sprinkled sugar on it. Overall it was a great dining experience and I look forward to trying their other foods one day soon! It's a great place to chill where you can grab some beer and snacks as you watch the game or shoot pool! There's also occasional events being hosted here so call in advance to inquire if there's any fun activities planned when you go Thank you for reading and best of luck! (:

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

New China Star Buffet
(328 review)
New China Star Buffet
  • 806 HWY 51 North, 806 U.S. 51 S, Covington, TN 38019, United States
chinese restaurant
+1 901-476-9790
Hot Chickz Chicken Sandwiches
(160 review)
Hot Chickz Chicken Sandwiches
  • 4242 Camino Del Rio N, San Diego, CA 92108, United States
Chicken restaurant
+1 619-269-5827
Cafe Venice
(279 review)
Cafe Venice
  • 49 High Street, Whitton, Twickenham TW2 7LB, United Kingdom
pizza restaurant
+44 20 8898 4000
Pupas kitchen/aunt Cheldas
(170 review)
Pupas kitchen/aunt Cheldas
  • 867 Meriden Rd, Waterbury, CT 06705, United States
Caribbean restaurant
+1 203-516-6895
Tomi's Home Style Cooking
(151 review)
Tomi's Home Style Cooking
  • Part 2, 17152 Parkinson Rd, Port Renfrew, BC V0S 1K0, Canada
Restaurant
+1 250-412-6099
Maxwells Caribbean/American Take-out
(450 review)
Maxwells Caribbean/American Take-out
  • 2200 N 17th St, Philadelphia, PA 19132, United States
caribbean restaurant
+1 215-787-2700
Terranova's Restaurant and Pizzeria
(1315 review)
Terranova's Restaurant and Pizzeria
  • 208 N State St, Bunnell, FL 32110, United States
Italian restaurant
+1 386-437-3101
Pizzaiolo
(180 review)
Pizzaiolo
  • 1528 Danforth Ave, Toronto, ON M4J 1N4, Canada
Pizza restaurant
+1 416-778-8899
Taller de Espresso, Expendio de cafe
(295 review)
Taller de Espresso, Expendio de cafe
  • Av. Enrique Ladron de Guevara 3023, Paseos del Sol, 45070 Zapopan, Jal., Mexico
cafeteria
+52 33 2737 7220
Natt Guadalupe
(323 review)
Natt Guadalupe
  • Blvd. Francisco I. Madero 701, Guadalupe, 25720 Monclova, Coah., Mexico
Health food restaurant
+52 866 635 1011